Umar Attacked the House of Fatimah, the Prophet’s Daughter
A Sunni Scholar Admits the Raid on the House of Fatimah (a.s.)
Hasan ibn Farhan al-Maliki in Qira'ah fi Kutub al-'Aqa'id: al-Madhhab al-Hanbali Namudhajan, p46
“I previously believed that the raid was fabricated and unauthentic, until I found strong chains supporting it, including what Ibn Abi Shaybah transmitted in al-Musannaf through an authentic chain from Aslam, the freedman of Umar, and other reports. However, it was not as exaggerated by the extremist Shia, nor as denied by the extremist Hanbalis.”
كنت أظن المداهمة مكذوبة لا تصح حتى وجدت لها أسانيد قوية منها ما أخرجه ابن أبي شيبة في المصنف بسند صحيح عن أسلم مولى عمر وغير ذلك، لكن ليس كما يبالغ غلاة الشيعة وليس كما ينفي غلاة الحنابلة.
